Black Death challenge: the “world's sourest candy” and its rivals

The Black Death challenge is eating Mr Simms' Black Death Ultra Sour, a British lemon sour ball sold as one of the world's sourest candies, on camera without flinching. No one has settled which candy is sourest: The Takeout names Black Death and Barnett's Mega Sours as the top contenders, and a CandyStore ranking put Toxic Waste first.

170Mviews on 18 Black Death TikToks we sampled
8+age on the packaging
2acids: citric and malic

Black Death took off on TikTok after a reaction video went viral, per The Daily Meal. In scout's 2026-11-10 TikTok sample, 18 Black Death videos had 170 million views, led by one at 101 million. Its packaging says it is not suitable for children under 8.

Price tables: SpicyExtreme foods

At a glance

ProductClaimLowest eBayAmazon
Mr Simms Black Death Mega Sours“World's most sour” contender$32.11Check price
Barnett's Mega Sours“World's most sour” contender$6.99Check price
Toxic Waste Hazardously Sour Candy#1 in CandyStore's ranking$9.95Check price
Warheads Extreme Sour Hard Candyranked above Mega Sours$10.80Check price

How the Black Death challenge works

It is a reaction challenge: the point is to keep a straight face while the sour coating lasts.

  1. Film yourself, or a friend who hasn't tried one, unwrapping a single Black Death ball.
  2. Put it in your mouth whole and keep it there; no chewing, no spitting.
  3. Hold your expression until the sour coating is gone, then show the candy to the camera.
  4. Step up: try Barnett's Mega Sours or Toxic Waste next and compare.

Do it safely

  • The packaging says it is not suitable for children under 8.
  • Stop at one or two: the packaging warns that eating too many in a short time can cause irritation.
  • Rinse with water afterward; skip it if your mouth has cuts or ulcers.

The contenders

Mr Simms Black Death Mega Sours

Mr Simms Black Death Mega Sours

“World's most sour” contender source

Invented by British confectioner Mr Simms Sweet Shop and “flavored with a mix of acidic ingredients, including citric acid and malic acid,” per The Daily Meal. The packaging warns about irritation if you eat too many in a short time.

Barnett's Mega Sours

Barnett's Mega Sours

“World's most sour” contender source

“Another contender to hold the crown of the world's sourest candy,” per The Takeout. Barnett's is also a British firm.

Toxic Waste Hazardously Sour Candy

Toxic Waste Hazardously Sour Candy

#1 in CandyStore's ranking source

The Takeout reports that CandyStore's sour ranking put Toxic Waste Hazardously Sour in the top spot.

Warheads Extreme Sour Hard Candy

Warheads Extreme Sour Hard Candy

ranked above Mega Sours source

In the same CandyStore ranking, Warheads Extreme Sour came ahead of Mega Sours, per The Takeout.

We earn a commission on purchases through these links. eBay prices (item + shipping) read from our latest check; Amazon links open a search, so check the price there. Listed in no particular order. Each figure is the maker’s or the named source’s claim, as of 2026-11-10.

Good to know

Watch the challenge

Videos open on YouTube. We don't make or endorse them; they show what the challenge looks like.

More extremes

Hottest gummy bear Hottest hot sauce Fire Noodle Challenge Sourest candy Biggest gummy candy Strongest coffee Hottest Takis Carolina Reaper Hottest candy Disturbing candy Freeze-dried candy Strongest energy drinks Ghost pepper Sourest gummies Hottest Tabasco sauce

Sources