One 12 oz cup of Black Label is almost four times the 400 mg a day the FDA cites as not generally linked to negative effects for most adults. These brands sell on that number, so brew them weaker than you would normal coffee.
Price tables: SpicyExtreme foods
At a glance
| Product | Caffeine (mg / 12 oz) | Lowest eBay | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|
Devil Mountain Black Label Coffee | 1,555 | $297 | Check price |
Black Insomnia Coffee | 1,105 | $14.49 | Check price |
Death Wish Coffee | 728 | $15.26 | Check price |
| Gunpowder Coffee | 644 | none listed | Check price |
Fire Department Coffee | 500 | $10.49 | Check price |
Banned Coffee | 474 | $21.47 | Check price |
How much is too much?
The FDA cites 400 mg a day as an amount not generally linked to negative effects for most adults. One 12 oz cup brewed at the makers' strength compares like this:
- Devil Mountain Black Label: 1,555 mg, nearly 4 times the 400 mg figure.
- Black Insomnia: 1,105 mg, about 2.8 times.
- Death Wish: 728 mg, about 1.8 times.
- Fire Department Coffee: 500 mg, 1.25 times.
Do it safely
- Brew these weaker or drink a smaller cup than usual.
- Count other caffeine too: energy drinks, tea, soda and pre-workout.
The coffees, strongest first


Black Insomnia Coffee
Listed at 1,105 mg per 12 fl oz brewed, second on Caffeine Informer's list of strongest coffee brands.

Death Wish Coffee
The brand that bills itself as the "world's strongest". Caffeine Informer lists 728 mg per 12 oz; Consumer Reports measured 59 mg per fluid ounce, or 708 mg in 12 oz.

Fire Department Coffee
Listed at 500 mg per 12 fl oz brewed, about two and a half tall Starbucks Dark Roasts.

Banned Coffee
Listed at 474 mg per 12 fl oz brewed, about two and a half times a tall Starbucks Dark Roast.
We earn a commission on purchases through these links. eBay prices (item + shipping) read from our latest check; Amazon links open a search, so check the price there. Listed in no particular order. Each figure is the maker’s or the named source’s claim, as of 2026-11-09.
Good to know
- Caffeine figures are as listed by Caffeine Informer (updated 29 April 2025); most are the makers' figures, not independent tests. Real cups vary with how much coffee you use and how you brew it.
- Consumer Reports tested Death Wish in 2016 at 59 mg per fluid ounce.
Watch strong-coffee tests
▶Testing one of the most caffeinated coffeesMorgan Eckroth · YouTube · 2021
▶The 5 strongest caffeinated coffees, reviewedHot Shots Coffee · YouTube · 2020
▶Devil Mountain Black Label reviewCoffeeology · YouTube · 2022Videos open on YouTube. We don't make or endorse them; they show what the challenge looks like.
More extremes
Hottest gummy bear Hottest hot sauce Fire Noodle Challenge Sourest candy Biggest gummy candy Hottest Takis Carolina Reaper Hottest candy Disturbing candy Black Death sour challenge Freeze-dried candy Strongest energy drinks Ghost pepper Sourest gummies Hottest Tabasco sauce
Sources
- Caffeine Informer: strongest coffee brands, updated 2025-04-29
- Consumer Reports: the buzz on Death Wish coffee, Feb 2016
- FDA: how much caffeine is too much, Aug 2024: “For most adults, the FDA has cited 400 milligrams a day”