Shuck or buy bare?

The cheapest new external desktop drive (WD Elements, Seagate Expansion) against the cheapest bare 3.5" drive at the same capacity, from US eBay Buy It Now listings, item + shipping. Last snapshot 2026-11-05.

CapacityExternal, newBare, newBare, usedVerdict
14 TB WD Elements external 14TB
$480 eBay → $34.28/TB
WD Ultrastar HC530 14TB
$402 eBay → $28.71/TB
WD Ultrastar HC530 14TB
$250 eBay → $17.86/TB
Buy bare: $77.95 cheaper
16 TB Seagate Expansion Desktop 16TB
$450 eBay → $28.12/TB
Seagate Exos X16 16TB
$505 eBay → $31.56/TB
Seagate Exos X18 16TB
$314 eBay → $19.62/TB
Shuck: saves $54.96
18 TB WD Elements external 18TB
$706 eBay → $39.20/TB
Toshiba MG09 18TB
$549 eBay → $30.50/TB
Seagate Exos X18 18TB
$349 eBay → $19.39/TB
Buy bare: $157 cheaper
20 TB WD Elements external 20TB
$760 eBay → $38.00/TB
Seagate Exos X20 20TB
$659 eBay → $32.94/TB
Seagate Exos X20 20TB
$477 eBay → $23.86/TB
Buy bare: $101 cheaper
22 TB WD Elements external 22TB
$699 eBay → $31.77/TB
WD Red Pro 22TB
$1,068 eBay → $48.55/TB
Seagate Exos X22 22TB
$637 eBay → $28.97/TB
Shuck: saves $369
24 TB Seagate Expansion Desktop 24TB
$680 eBay → $28.33/TB
Seagate IronWolf Pro 24TB
$888 eBay → $36.99/TB
Seagate Exos X24 24TB
$669 eBay → $27.88/TB
Shuck: saves $208

What shucking costs you

Shucking means taking the drive out of an external enclosure to use it internally. The drive inside is usually a white-label WD or Seagate drive, but which model you get is not guaranteed, the warranty is generally voided once the case is opened, and some WD drives need the 3.3 V pin taped before they spin up in older power supplies. A bare drive avoids all three. Used bare drives are often the cheapest per TB; check their hours and SMART data with the seller.

Each figure is the single cheapest clean listing, so open it before buying; parts, lots and broken units are filtered out (how we price).

Storage price per TB, new vs used · All external drives · All storage with price history